Have both of the 09 games for Wii. I will tell impressions. I ahven't played Madden yet though. As far as Tiger, seems good so far except putting is horrible.

...

On tiger woods in ym very first round of golf I just got an eagle on hole 15 of the new year's day cup. It was an unbelievable shot! I was close to 200 yards from the hole, I swung, the ball hit the ground way to the left and way short of the hole and then it rolled extremely fast at a very sharp angle to the right and went in! I don't recall ever making such a cool shot in any gold game. I'm mad there is no way to save the shot to view later. It was amazing. It was such a sharp, perfect angle.